Difference between revisions of "Talk:NicoTube Transpacifica"
(Inquiry about removal) |
imported>CrazyGamer339 |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | ==Original talk post== | ||
Hi, I'm the guy that created the NicoTube Transpacifica page. I saw that it got removed. I was under the impression that amateurs putting their medleys under the "Medleys by Database Forum Members" was fair game. Is this not the case? To be frank, I've noticed that some of the other entries "by Database Forum Members" are of somewhat questionable quality. For example, the ones posted by DJ Lady Rainicorn (thereallynewmop12100). I do not mean this to be disparaging, but if all of those mixes are acceptable for the wiki, then I do not see why mine was not, as I believe my mix is of superior quality to theirs. | Hi, I'm the guy that created the NicoTube Transpacifica page. I saw that it got removed. I was under the impression that amateurs putting their medleys under the "Medleys by Database Forum Members" was fair game. Is this not the case? To be frank, I've noticed that some of the other entries "by Database Forum Members" are of somewhat questionable quality. For example, the ones posted by DJ Lady Rainicorn (thereallynewmop12100). I do not mean this to be disparaging, but if all of those mixes are acceptable for the wiki, then I do not see why mine was not, as I believe my mix is of superior quality to theirs. | ||
If this is somehow fair, then I will leave the page removed as it is now. Perhaps there is some rule that I have missed here? Please let me know. However, if no good reason can be provided why my medley should not be allowed on the wiki while others of inferior quality remain, then I feel the page should be reverted. Thanks. | If this is somehow fair, then I will leave the page removed as it is now. Perhaps there is some rule that I have missed here? Please let me know. However, if no good reason can be provided why my medley should not be allowed on the wiki while others of inferior quality remain, then I feel the page should be reverted. Thanks. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===My thoughts=== | ||
| + | |||
| + | Hello, CrazyGamer339 here. Although I believe the wording in one part did make the response seem a bit aggressive (no offense, by the way) I am on your side here. If there's an composer category on this wiki dedicated to medleys by the members of this small community on the wiki and forums, I see no reason for why the page was erased. I, for one, thought it was a great concept to combine songs from all over the internet, and amazing for someone's first medley. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[User:CrazyGamer339|CrazyGamer339]] 22:52, 30 March 2016 (PDT) | ||
Revision as of 05:52, 31 March 2016
Original talk post
Hi, I'm the guy that created the NicoTube Transpacifica page. I saw that it got removed. I was under the impression that amateurs putting their medleys under the "Medleys by Database Forum Members" was fair game. Is this not the case? To be frank, I've noticed that some of the other entries "by Database Forum Members" are of somewhat questionable quality. For example, the ones posted by DJ Lady Rainicorn (thereallynewmop12100). I do not mean this to be disparaging, but if all of those mixes are acceptable for the wiki, then I do not see why mine was not, as I believe my mix is of superior quality to theirs.
If this is somehow fair, then I will leave the page removed as it is now. Perhaps there is some rule that I have missed here? Please let me know. However, if no good reason can be provided why my medley should not be allowed on the wiki while others of inferior quality remain, then I feel the page should be reverted. Thanks.
My thoughts
Hello, CrazyGamer339 here. Although I believe the wording in one part did make the response seem a bit aggressive (no offense, by the way) I am on your side here. If there's an composer category on this wiki dedicated to medleys by the members of this small community on the wiki and forums, I see no reason for why the page was erased. I, for one, thought it was a great concept to combine songs from all over the internet, and amazing for someone's first medley.
CrazyGamer339 22:52, 30 March 2016 (PDT)
